Just come back from Prometheus on the big screen in 3D. And just as expected it's a visual spectacle. Some images will last me a long time. Beautiful, scary, just wow.
The sound (as separate from the music) is awesome as well. You are really trembling in your seat when a spaceship blasts overhead.
And it's well paced in terms of action, building up in steady crescendo. It's a chain reaction with few let ups. I'm still releasing tension. So that part of the movie worked very well.
...spoilers from here
The actions of the scientists are just unbelievable unprofessional. No archeologist worth his salt would interfere with the find. Noone would just take of their helmets (especially not later, when you've decided this is a hostile environment).
Also, how can two men get lost in a system that is being mapped by one of them, and while they have constant contact with the ship's crew?
Since when do biologists try to make friends with animals clearly showing their not friendly when you know the environment is hostile?
Why does the captain leave his post when there are lifeforms at large and two of his men out when he know something bad has happened out there?
Why does the face of the decapitated alien look serene, rather than smashed?
But more basically: why are cannisters with very dangerous weaponry neatly arrayed in a room with ceremonial function? And why would people try to hide there?
And how does the captain suddenly understand that the base is meant as a WMD production facility? He hasn't been down in the base and not put any time into tying all the ends together, rather the opposite. He's ignored lots of info.
Ok, suppose you just auto-removed an alien embryo and then had your belly stapled... You then run into the guy that's tried to freeze you in while carrying the embryo. You then just talk to him? You don't try and put a bullet in his head?
And you don't tell anybody of the squid lingering in the operation room? Not even the cleaner?
I also see serious issues of continuity with Alien (the sequel). The guy they're supposed to find in the control room (I always thought he was manning the gun, but that's another story) in Alien. has left. In Alien, nobody notices the remnants of the Prometheus, close by, let alone the human remains of the prometheus crew in the control room.
And actingwise, the performance by David the android with his love for Lawrence of Arabia is very good. All the other roles, I think, are forgettable.
I just don't know why Scott chose to go this way. The original Alien works much better in terms of suspense and pacing, while at the same time keeping the movie coherent. The acting gets much more time to shine making it interesting from that point of view as well. This all makes the choices and actions of those involved much more believable.
Is the modern blockbuster just incapable of telling a good story, so as not to interfere with the action sequences? Makes me sad.
But let's start on a positive note: the Engineer at the start of the movie, who drinks a cup and dissolves. What was he drinking. Why did he do it? Guilt? Suicide? As a means to start the outbreak? Fascinating and unresolved in the movie.
This is just my take. There's a much better review from a more cinematically versed Scott fan that I really recommend.
ps I have started blogging in my own place as well, because there's stuff that doesn't fit in with F:AT. Have a look if you like. Upside is: since I will be blogging more, more stuff will end up here as well.