- Posts: 1683
- Thank you received: 621
Bugs: Recent Topics Paging, Uploading Images & Preview (11 Dec 2020)
Recent Topics paging, uploading images and preview bugs require a patch which has not yet been released.
Selling MTG cards advice
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Michael Barnes
- Offline
- Mountebank
- HYPOCRITE
- Posts: 16929
- Thank you received: 10375
But yeah, if its legit, then this is a major find, no doubt. I told him I'd like to see pictures for an article, I really want to see what he produces. That may tell all right there.
Counterfeit cards is another possibility.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- san il defanso
- Offline
- D10
- ENDUT! HOCH HECH!
- Posts: 4623
- Thank you received: 3560
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
I fixed this for you.Michael Barnes wrote: Yeah, if it is a con, he's definitely going long with it...but the thing is, this is the kind of thing that does happen occasionally with collectibles...somebody finds a Davinci sketch used as a book mark in a garage sale copy of The Joy of Cooking or something. It's not outside the realm of possibility.
But yeah, if its legit, then this is a major find, no doubt. I told him I'd like to see pictures for an article, I really want to see what he produces. That may tell all right there.
Counterfeit cards is.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Posts: 947
- Thank you received: 878
Michael Barnes wrote: Yeah, if it is a con, he's definitely going long with it...but the thing is, this is the kind of thing that does happen occasionally with collectibles...somebody finds a Davinci sketch used as a book mark in a garage sale copy of The Joy of Cooking or something. It's not outside the realm of possibility.
Hell, there's at least one story like that in each episode of Antiques Road Show, if not multiple stories. Of course this Magic find strains credulity, but on the other hand it was found in a card collector's collection. It'd be (more) fishy if the only collectibles in the estate were Precious Moments figurines, or something like that.
Of course, I was one of those hopeful souls who bought one of those "discovered" Heroscape Wave 9 booster packs from eBay a few weeks ago where it turned out to be a SKU error, so I suppose you could color me optimistic about these sorts of things.
Also, I'm not familiar with counterfeit Magic cards, so how easy would it be to fool game shop owners who sell them? Are the fakes usually that good?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Posts: 1683
- Thank you received: 621
I'd say it might be easy-ish to fool a small-time game shop owner, harder to fool a big-time retailer who has someone on staff who specializes in early cards. One fake I bought (and caught, and returned) was from a medium-sized retailer with a very good reputation.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Michael Barnes
- Offline
- Mountebank
- HYPOCRITE
- Posts: 16929
- Thank you received: 10375
This is why getting very valuable cards graded and appraised is important...experts know what to look for, and it's not always obvious stuff. There might have been a tiny smudge or hair or piece of dust on the original plate that the card was printed from that doesn't show up in a forgery. Or there can be misaligned text or images from scanning/duplication. Colors can be off, images can be off-center, and so forth.
Small shops don't tend to appraise cards in the same way, but they also don't tend to be in the market for $1000+ cards The bigger shops that do a larger collectors' business are the ones that are going to really do the tests.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Do you ever get guys turning up to big conventions and tournaments with home printed or even hand drawn Black Loter cards? I would so totally do that
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
ldsdbomber wrote: Do you ever get guys turning up to big conventions and tournaments with home printed or even hand drawn Black Loter cards? I would so totally do that
I would totally pay to see you show up to play at a tourney with a hand drawn Black Loter card.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Michael Barnes
- Offline
- Mountebank
- HYPOCRITE
- Posts: 16929
- Thank you received: 10375
Some tournaments actually do allow proxies like that, they tend to be more causal and not like national championships or anything like that.
The point of the rarity has become somewhat obscured. When Magic first came out, the idea was that the rarer cards would be extremely powerful but actually have less utility than, say, a 1 CC creature with flying. They'd be harder to use. But some cards, like the Moxes and Black Lotus, were actually STUPIDLY powerful AND useful- so they were quickly restricted or even banned.
But you see, at first Magic was written to be an _ante_ game. You could put that really rare Black Lotus in your deck, but you'd be _risking_ it. As written in the first editions of Magic, both players put a random card from their deck on the table as stakes, with the winner taking the loser's card. There were specific cards that affected ante in some of the earliest sets.
But it didn't pan out like that. People didn't play ante, largely because they came to realize that certain cards were exceptionally rare, and even at that early stage quite valuable because they were desirable and in demand. I don't think Garfield and co. initially realized that there would be a collector's market, singles sales, and all of that. I think they really thought that the rarity would be a factor in ante play. I don't think they realized that people would go out and spend $100+ to get four Royal Assassins and four Oubliettes.
What they didn't count on was the psychological power-trip/competitive angle of the game, the metagame, and the speculator market getting in on it. At first, rarity wasn't even printed on the cards. The first packs I opened I had no idea what the rares were. We started to see that some cards were obviously more common- I'd have five Benalish Heroes but I'd see a Force of Nature and had no idea where the hell that card came from.
That was really an awesome stage for Magic, this kind of wild frontier atmosphere it had. Five color, 70 card decks with everything but the kitchen sink in them. Constant speculation that the next set was going to introduce ORANGE or RAINBOW mana. Discovering those first two card and three card combos.
Now, the rarity is still an important part of the competitive tournament scene and organized play, especially sealed deck/booster draft events. It really serves WotC no financial purpose to NOT just run off sheets and sheets of Black Lotuses. But it affects how the game is played, what cards are in the mix, and what is going on in the metagame.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Black Barney
- Offline
- D20
- 10k Club
- Posts: 10045
- Thank you received: 3553
I didn't know forging Magic cards was actually a big deal but yeah I guess it makes sense. They should make a sequel to The Counterfeiters and have them doing Magic cards.
/offensive
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Ante was not stopped because people didn't play ante--it was in the rules. Ante was stopped because it's gambling. It's children: gambling. The game was popular beyond their wildest imagining, the secondary market formed and was robust, and all of a sudden kids were crying to Mom about losing their Juzam in ante and the lawyers said, yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaah.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
jeb wrote: Until very recently, no rares were more or less rare than any others. Black Lotus was printed as many times as Blaze of Glory. But one of them is amazing, and one is a piece of shit. Being able to tell the difference is the game.
Ante was not stopped because people didn't play ante--it was in the rules. Ante was stopped because it's gambling. It's children: gambling. The game was popular beyond their wildest imagining, the secondary market formed and was robust, and all of a sudden kids were crying to Mom about losing their Juzam in ante and the lawyers said, yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaah.
The point is rares are no longer printed~
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- ChristopherMD
- Away
- Road Warrior
- Posts: 5238
- Thank you received: 3789
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Posts: 1683
- Thank you received: 621
Back in the day, there theoretically was a deck that was unbeatable on the first turn 99% of the time...just pack your deck full of Black Lotuses, Fireballs, and Channels. But it would have been incredibly difficult given that Lotus and Channel are both rare.
As for why the supply of Black Lotus is "artificially limited"...i.e. why don't they just print more? It's complicated. Back in the day, there was a set printed called Chronicles; it reprinted some of the big hits from the extremely rare Arabian Nights, Legends, etc., including the Elder Dragon Legends. People who had spent a bunch of money to acquire those cards saw the value of those cards drop down to zilch because so much Chronicles was printed. People left Magic because of it. Huge outcry. So Wizards made a list of cards, the Reserve List, and promised to never reprint anything on it ever again. This list, of course, includes the Power 9. Every set had to add a few cards to the reserve list, until they decided that the whole idea was a terrible one, and stopped adding cards (and also scaled back the list a bit).
A few years back, in a very limited edition boxed set, they reprinted a few Reserve List cards; nothing too crazy valuable, and they used a loophole that allowed them to print FOIL versions of the Reserve List cards. There were then two completely mysterious meetings at Wizards headquarters: one had Stephen Menendian (outspoken promoter of Vintage Magic, which allows the Power 9), Ben Bleiweiss (owner of StarCityGames), and more. The other group, we know nothing about. The topic of discussion: abolishing the reserve list. Both Stephen and Ben were in favor of abolishing it.
The following week, Wizards officially stated that they would *not* use foils to break the Reserve List ever again, and made their Reserve List promise even stronger. No one who works at Wizards or who went to those mysterious meetings is ever allowed to talk about it.
So that's why they'll never print another Black Lotus, even though of course, it would make a ton of money for Wizards.
This month, however, they *are* reprinting the most expensive card of the modern era, "Jace, the Mind Sculptor", whose prices were around $150 before the announcement. Not to mention they just did "Modern Masters", which was basically Chronicles Redux, and reprinted a crapton of expensive cards. But all from post-Reserve List.
Every Vintage tournament in the USA except one allows proxies, by the way. So yes, people do show up to tournaments with "Black Lotus" scrawled in sharpie on a land, and get to treat it as such.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.