Articles Reviews Barnestorming #35- Best of 2011, Sherlock, Arcade Fire
 

Barnestorming #35- Best of 2011, Sherlock, Arcade Fire Hot

Barnestorming #35- Best of 2011, Sherlock, Arcade Fire

Scissors should have put some money down on my picks, because he nailed every one of them.

On the Table

I have rendered my decision at Gameshark.com. In the five (!) years I’ve been doing Cracked LCD, this was by far the best all-around year for game releases. It was also the hardest in terms of isolating what I wanted to name Game of the Year. I used the same format as last year, offering a top five and then the big prize. But in all honesty, I could have slated any of my Final Five in the top slot and felt comfortable with the pick. You can probably guess what five of the picks are, the sixth you might not have expected.

I haven’t played a board game in weeks. I’ve been in baby jail since before Christmas with my wife on a couple of ridiculously long shoot days. Hoping to get over to Frank’s to try Colonial soon so that Chapel and I can continue our courtship.

Also hot to get the new Evo to the table…have you guys seen this? The artwork is freaking awesome, the production is just spectacular. I love that they went with a very Metal Hurlant style and I like that it’s not just random dino mutation…players are genetic alchemists or whatever tampering with nature. Totally bad ass. I always liked Evo a lot but I haven’t played it since before Atlanta Game Factory. Eager to revisit it in light of Small World and Olympos.

 

On the Consoles

Dust. On hiatus until the January releases start rolling out. Really needed a break after the Fall and Winter onslaught.

We do have a couple of new writers over at No High Scores. One of them is an English Country Gentleman named Matt Thrower.

 

On the iDevices

But don’t think I haven’t been playing video games. I’ve just about wore the touchscreen off the iPad. Good god, what a great way to play games.Play a space 4x game like the MOO2 clone Starbase Orion and it’s like THE FUTURE looking at all of those maps, charts, and readouts.

I’ve been hitting Ascension awfully hard with like six concurrent games going on at once, including some with F:ATties. I very nearly listed the app as one of my top games of 2011. It just amazes me how well that game- which was really kind of average on the table- translated to IOS and async multiplayer. I kind of hooked, and now I’m getting that “It is now your turn in a game of Ascension” message constantly. But I still can’t win the damn game. I beat some random last night in a savage beatdown, but everybody else has beat the tar out of me. I do wonder if the game’s uptake and success is because it’s the only deckbuilder on IOS right now other than Gundabad. I wonder how the AEG titles and the official Dominion app will affect the player base.

I’ve also played some Kingdom Rush, which is a really good and god damned hard TD. I do like a good TD, and I do like a god damned hard one.

Also having a daily dose of one or more of the Cave shooters, I love the IOS version of Deathsmiles. The terrible Lolita stuff is actually toned down somewhat, and they’ve added a new mode where you can buy stuff and upgrade so there’s more depth. I’m also favoring Bug Princess (Mushihimesama), it’s simple but the Nausicaa-like theme is very cool. Espaluda II is tough, particularly if you’re like me an insist on playing the hardest difficulty and with the full control options.

The thing that’s really amazing about those games is how well they work on a touchscreen- even on the iPhone. I thought it would be a disaster. But Cave has the controls nailed, and it’s actually BETTER than an arcade stick or a D-pad. The precision is higher, and it makes bobbing and weaving through the hail of bullets even more exciting.

Ghost Stories and Forbidden Island continue to kick my ass mercilessly.

 

On the Screen

Speaking of Ghost Stories…I saw Ching Siu Tung’s 1987 wuxia classic A Chinese Ghost Story on Netflix so I had to watch it. I have never seen the film in any format other than an umpteenth generation VHS copy, so it was really kind of amazing to be able to actually see the film. It’s all wide angle lenses, color gels, and dolly-ups so it looks like a total mess with a low quality image. If you like Ghost Stories (the game), you have to see this film because about 80% of the game is in this movie with the other 20% falling somewhere along the Mr. Vampire/Swordsman/Bride With White Hair/Holy Virgin versus the Evil Dead axis. When a move starts out with a thousand year old tree demon attacking folks with a giant tongue that splits apart to reveal a face and tentacles, where do you go from there?

NOW…last night, I thought I’d check out the BBC’s Sherlock. I had heard it was pretty good. If you are a F:ATtie that has watched and enjoyed this show, all I have to say is THANKS A FUCKING LOT for not telling me about it. It is AMAZING. I would go so far as to say that it’s one of the best TV shows I’ve seen in a long, long time.

It’s absolutely brilliant. If you’ve not seen it, it’s Sherlock Holmes transposed to modern-day London. That may sound like crap, but the showrunners are Stephen Moffat and the Doctor Who folks, and they TOTALLY get that Holmes is really kind of an intellectual superhero that is also, as he puts it in the show, a high-functioning sociopath.

Benedict Cumberbatch is FUCKING AWESOME as Holmes, there’s no other way to put it. His body language, his posture, his cutting remarks, the way his eyes dart around, looking for something to hang his devastating insight on…this man IS Holmes. Martin Campbell as an Afghan war vet Watson is a pitch-perfect foil, and both the chemistry between the actors and the writing is nothing short of sensational.

I just watched the first episode (which is really a 90 minute feature-length story) and it was just stunning. The story definitely takes cues from Doyle and it’s totally an old fashioned parlour mystery, with Holmes explaining all the wrongdoing that’s gone on off camera in breathless, stylized rushes of deduction. But it’s witty and very modern, and the writers play with the Holmes character- winking at the “is he gay” question, teasing Moriarty, and playing a fun bait-and-switch about the seven percent solution issue. The idea of Holmes being a big texter might seem a little contrived, but it totally works.

Great, great show. I can’t wait to see the rest of them.

Doing the Wikipedia rounds afterwords, Cumberbatch is apparently playing Smaug against Campbell’s Hobbit. Wow. Also, if there is ever to be a Sandman movie, my vote is for Cumberbatch as Morpheous.

Also, Benedict Cumberbatch is the best name since Flaster Siskin.


On Spotify

I was happy to see that apparently the Arcade Fire finally signed the papers to put their three records on Spotify particulary since I still haven’t listened to their last one, The Suburbs, yet. Sure, they were the indie darlings of what, 2004 and they’re almost unbelievably precious but I really like their Bunnymen meets Springsteen meets Pixies schtick.

So I started listening to The Suburbs, got bored with it, and went back to listening to Funeral and Neon Bible. Go figure.

I’m in the minority I guess, but I greatly prefer Neon Bible to Funeral. Don’t get me wrong- when Funeral is on, it’s ON. “Neighborhood #3- Power Out” and “Rebellion: Lies” are two of the best songs recorded in the past decade. But Neon Bible is a little tougher, more Eddie and The Cruisers and less Canadian-sounding- see “Keep the Car Running”. And you’ve got “Intervention” on there, which could almost have been a cut off of “Ocean Rain” in an alternate dimension.

Maybe I’ll try The Suburbs again. But I kind of feel like I might be hitting the British Sea Power catalog next.

Powered by JReviews
Comments (68)
  • avatarSan Il Defanso

    I genuinely loved The Suburbs. I'm not sure precisely why it resonated with me so much, but it was easily my favorite album of 2010. It's definitely the first album of theirs where I've loved every song without reservation. It's a long listen, and it does take some effort, but it's paid off handsomely for me so far.

    I feel like some kind of board gaming lightweight, but I still haven't played many 2011 releases. That seems like a good list though. Eclipse sounds so much like my kind of game, it's a little frightening.

    An honorable mention section would have been cool too, but this year that would probably have been too long to be feasible.

  • avatarChapel
    Quote:
    Hoping to get over to Frank’s to try Colonial soon so that Chapel and I can continue our courtship

    Ah yes. It's like Age of Renaissance wearing spanx.

    It's the good stuff.

  • avatarJonJacob

    I had myself some Baby Jail time this Christmas but luckily my kid is young enough that I can still play a solo game or video game while he's playing on the floor.

    Nice list. I don't see how any game could be more progressive and interesting a design then Mage Knight this year. As awesome as Eclipse looks it's still a DoaM and that is a pretty crowded space whereas Mage Knight feels unlike anything I've ever played. Even other adventure games. It doesn't even really replace anything so much as stake new ground.

    It still blows me away and I'm really anxious to get some other players into it becuase I think the other scenario's could be really incredible with the right group.

  • avatarscissors

    Ahhhhh crap! I didn't really think I would hit
    them although I did read your reviews consistently this year. Three were obvious that they had to be there to anyone who followed GShark - Eclipse, CE, MK. The other two I got lucky :/ Im glad you gave it to MK though.

  • avatarlj1983

    we've definetely enjoyed BBC's Sherlock. At first I really disliked the sherlock character, as he is a real prick. but he grows on you...and frankly sherlock is supposed to be a prick.

  • avatarBulwyf
    Quote:
    If you are a F:ATtie that has watched and enjoyed this show, all I have to say is THANKS A FUCKING LOT for not telling me about it. It is AMAZING


    Hey I posted on the Fort right after I watched the show on PBS. Not my fault you missed it, but I am glad you enjoyed it. I sincerely hope they do more.

    -Will

  • avatarstormseeker75

    Winner of the best name ever: Benedict Cumberbatch.

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    Oh, I like that he's an ass.He's the smartest guy in the room, and he knows it. I really like how arrogant he is, it's refreshing in a world when everything is geared to be mediocre and non-exceptional for a character to recognize his intellectual superiority and flaunt it. "It must be dreadfully boring to be you".

    One of my favorite beats was when he was profiling the lady in pink and figured out that she had a daughter that had been dead for 14 years. He says something like "that doesn't make sense, why would she still be sad?" and everyone is just kind of looking at him.

    And yes, Holmes is supposed to be a prick!

  • avatarBullwinkle

    BBC One just premiered the second season of Sherlock.

  • avatarMattLoter

    We loved the BCC Sherlock when we watched them a month or two ago.

    Yomi and Eclpise are two very meh games, don't get the love affair either seem to have spawned. Though no one seem to talk about Yomi much anymore eh?

  • avatarAncient_of_MuMu

    Love Sherlock and can't wait for Season 2 to be finished.

    I thought Arcade Fire's The Suburbs was mediocre when I first heard it as I love Neon Bible so much (probably my 3rd or 4th favourite album of all time). But slowly I gave it more and more of a chance, and will admit now that it has about 10-12 great songs on it in the middle, it just starts and ends weakly. Now, it is probably my favourite album of 2010, edging out LCD Soundsystem's This is Happening (which is half brilliant, half terrible) and Grinderman 2 (most solid all round effort with no weak songs, but minimal great tracks).

  • avatarSpace Ghost

    I am successfully trading my copy of Yomi for Dragon Pass....so, I am about as happy as can be to be rid of it. For me, the 2-player card game slot is just too crowded with better games

    Magic the Gathering
    Summoner Wars
    Omen
    The Battle for Hill 218
    Battleline
    INWO


    Hell, I even rank Spellfire above Yomi. Otherwise, I agree on all accounts (excepting Eclipse, which I haven't even seen a copy of yet)

  • avatardragonstout

    Suburbs is my favorite Arcade Fire album, by far. I was bored the first couple times I listened to it too, and now every time I listen to it every single song just sounds incredibly intense and fills me full of strong emotions. Easily my favorite album of the last couple years.

    I knew exactly what the top 5 games would be, didn't guess Blood Bowl Team Manager (didn't remember that there was actually going to be 6, was shocked when I came to #1 and hadn't seen Mage Knight yet! In fact, almost didn't click to the next page; you might want to renumber), thought King of Tokyo was going to be below Yomi, and thought you'd choose Eclipse over Mage Knight because it exemplified the "year of simplification" better.

    Dying for that King of Tokyo reprint, that's an auto-buy. Eclipse and Mage Knight I'm still on the fence on (my TI3-killers are Diplomacy or Dune, not Eclipse). With BB:TM I'm just completely turned off by the fact that it's a card-gameification of a board game. Cave Evil, the art looks awesome but so completely uninterested in death metal, and it looks like it'd be hard to get friends to play.

    I'm actually hoping for fewer cool games next year because I like reading your non-reviews better than your reviews of new games! They're usually more passionate. Kinda skimmed over the last half-year of your columns, no offense, I'm sure for people who are into buying the latest games ASAP they're useful.

  • avatarJosh Look

    The Suburbs is completely boring. Neon Bible rules, and I never really saw the huge appeal in Funeral until something in Neon Bible really made the band click as a whole for me. I love both now, but Neon Bible remains my favorite. The Suburbs, however...completely disappointing.

  • avatarEgg Shen

    Nice game of the year report. It really sucks that I haven't played ANY of these, but I've limited my spending on boardgames these days. Regardless here are my thoughts.

    Blood Bowl - I really want to get my hands on this card game. The blood bowl tie-in is great and this is one I will surely purchase in the future. I was so happy when the positive reviews came flooding in for this one.

    Yomi - This game doesn't really do much for me. Plus can anyone tell me why this game is so goddamn expensive? Its just a couple decks of cards right? I don't know...I guess I'd rather just fire up Nighwarriors: Darkstalker's Revenge on the Sega Saturn.

    King of Tokyo - I would already own this if it wasn't out of print. At least the dice will be improved in the second printing...this can't come fast enough though.

    Cave Evil - CE sounds downright awesome. I would never be able to get anyone to play this with me though.

    Eclipse - This sounds like everything I've ever wanted in a space empire game. I'll wait a few months for the hype to die down and see if it has any legs...my gut tells me that it will.

    Mage Knight - This is money already spent. The minute I can afford it I will be buying this. I think Vlaada is one of the best designers out there and if this is his crowing achievement then I need to get my hands on it.

    Thanks again for the good read!

  • avatarSchweig!

    When did British Sea Power become popular?

  • avatarDogmatix
    Quote:
    When did BSP become popular?

    The latest record seems to have rekindled some broader interest. I presumed it was a residual effect of going on the road with Manic Street Preachers and US TV appearance(s) early last year. I was surprised when I heard they were going to be on Letterman's show as they hadn't crossed my radar [not that I was paying particularly close attention] since catching them at a bar in 2004.

  • avatarmoofrank  - Jekyll

    After watching Sherlock, you need to look at Jekyll. Same kind of overly intelligent Stephen Moffat dialog and reimagining, but the actual acting...

    Wow. It is like every second he is about to become completely unglued, but it also fully in control of everything at all times.

    I'll agree wholeheartedly with Eclipse and Mage Knight, but miss Ascending Empires, Risk Legacy, Wiroqcha, and Junta: Viva El Presidente, and Nerath.

    ...and I haven't gotten to Colonies yet. That looks really good, and is a pretty definite hybrid.

    On Chinese Ghost Story....have you ever looked for a subbed copy of Crazy Safari? It is basically the exact same movie The Gods Must Be Crazy except that the tribe finds a Hopping Ghost instead of a coke bottle. Seriously. It is almost followable without subs, but the one lone Buford Highway video rental place that would speak to non-asians had a copy without english subs.

  • avatarBrewmiester  - re:
    stormseeker75 wrote:
    Winner of the best name ever: Benedict Cumberbatch.

    He's in the remake of Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy that opens today.

  • avatarStonecutter  - re:
    Michael Barnes wrote:
    Oh, I like that he's an ass.He's the smartest guy in the room, and he knows it. I really like how arrogant he is, it's refreshing in a world when everything is geared to be mediocre and non-exceptional for a character to recognize his intellectual superiority and flaunt it. "It must be dreadfully boring to be you".

    One of my favorite beats was when he was profiling the lady in pink and figured out that she had a daughter that had been dead for 14 years. He says something like "that doesn't make sense, why would she still be sad?" and everyone is just kind of looking at him.

    And yes, Holmes is supposed to be a prick!

    You've basically described House.

  • avatarBullwinkle  - re: re:
    Stonecutter wrote:
    You've basically described House.


    Who is himself a re-imagining of Sherlock Holmes.

  • avatarMattDP

    I've been in "baby jail" (I love that term, where's that from?) for coming up on two years now. Mine don't sleep - I think it must be something genetic they inherited from me. If I can get out for two hours once a month I count myself lucky. I'm heartily sick of it, like to the point of throwing myself out of a window sick of it.

    I've managed to avoid Sherlock so far but I have the latest series recorded on PVR as I kept on hearing good things about it. So I skipped that section for fear of spoilers.

    Amused that after you slated my own GOTY list you agreed with two of my picks, and put a third on as a near miss :) Neither the theme of mechanics of Yomi interest me at all. I can't get Cave Evil easily in the UK and while I've heard a lot of good things about it, I've heard no reason so far as to why the game is particularly different or unusual enough within it's genre to be outstanding. Also with "baby jail" time, it's not going to get played so I'm not biting. Similar with Eclipse although it interests me rather more. I'm starting to think that it's sounding more like a particularly good Euro-DOAM than a traditional 4X game. Not that that's a criticism - there are some superb Euro-DOAM designs around and Eclipse is likely to ride high amongst them, but the more I hear the more I'm thinking it sounds like it's not going to be a TI3 replacement after all. Mage Knight on the other hand does sound like something new and refreshing - the adventure game genre has been stultifying for years and really needed a kick up the backside. I just ordered a copy.

  • avatarCitadel

    Sherlock is by the current writers of Doctor Who.

    A friend has Mage Knight. I haven't played it yet but I looked through the box and glanced over the rules. This game is way overpriced in the UK. Eight horribly painted low detail figures, some hexes for a map and a stack of cards for the equivalent of $100. You have to be kidding. That is easily twice the price of the equivalent from FFG or Hasbro.

    I don't get the attraction of British Sea Power. Same with Hope of the States. The original eighties shoegaze stuff is way better. I have recommended friends who like British Sea Power that they should listen to Fourteen Autumns and Fifteen Winters and they have loved it. Or listen to some Slint, Mogwai, Godspeed You Black Emperor.....

  • avatarSka_baron

    Um, am I really going to be the first to toss a congrats to Mr. Thrower on landing a NHS gig? Sweet!

  • avatarBrewmiester  - re:
    Space Ghost wrote:
    I am successfully trading my copy of Yomi for Dragon Pass....so, I am about as happy as can be to be rid of it.


    Hope you have more luck than me getting it on the table. The last time I played DP was the late 80's. It is a gorgeous, crazy game.

  • avatarSpace Ghost

    And you with Yomi -- my group just never wants to play it with all the other competing 2-player games (primarily, Summoner Wars and MtG). Both me and the other guy that has it are getting rid of Yomi -- good for you that we played his copy as the one you will be receiving is in pristine condition.

  • avatarSagrilarus  - re:

    I don't see why someone would play Yomi if Summoner Wars is available.

    S.

  • avatarSpace Ghost

    Sag, you really wouldn't. And, for all the gushing about Yomi and how it simulates a fighting video game, no one ever really talks about how it leaves out one of the most strategic elements of those games -- being able to "pin" your opponent against the side (the ropes if you will)

  • avatarStormcow

    Despite being both card games, they are different enough that I feel you can't really make a direct comparison. It's like comparing M:tG to Tichu.

    I will say though, that my first couple of games with Summoner Wars were drab enough that I traded it away. I still enjoy Yomi as a light filler, even if it's not GOTY material.

  • avatarSuperflyTNT  - re:
    Space Ghost wrote:
    Sag, you really wouldn't. And, for all the gushing about Yomi and how it simulates a fighting video game, no one ever really talks about how it leaves out one of the most strategic elements of those games -- being able to "pin" your opponent against the side (the ropes if you will)

    LOL, as a guy who grew up around a bunch of Vietnamese Street Fighter Wunderkinds I believe this technique is called "CHEAPING" (sic).

    Yomi blows. What made Street Fighter (or Mortal Kombat) great wasn't the strategy, it was the twitch-factor reflex testing. It was the ability to buffet your opponent with so many combinations (uppercut, high kick, high kick, "hooo nooooougat" or whatever he says). Nobody on the planet has ever called Street Fighter an epic strategy game.

    Summoner Wars, for as much as I'm sick of it and will likely never play it again, is simply amazing. The fact is that there has not been a single game that I can think of on the planet that does what it does, let alone as well.

    Interesting choices, Michael. Unfortunately, I will absolutely not get to play most of them. Such is life... >:(

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    OK, movie, TV, music stuff:

    Crazy Safari...oh my god...that's definitely one of the more ridiculous HK movies. I never found a subbed copy of it, so it's even weirder when you can't understand what is going on other than that N!xau (yes, the same aborigine that was in The Gods Must Be Crazy) channels the spirit of Bruce Lee as evidenced by bootleg Game of Death footage during battles with hopping vampires.

    Oh, Hong Kong...I'm kind of in the mood to watch some of the more obnoxious ones...Deadful Melody, Naked Killer, Encounters of the Spooky Kind II, Eagle Shooting Heroes...at one point, I had literally every Hong Kong movie you could probably name. I think I had somewhere close to 400 titles sometime around 1997/1998.

    I'm definitely hitting Jekyll next.

    I never really thought about it, but House really is a direct ancestor of Sherlock Holmes. The characters are very similar, it's just that House's instinct for detection is purely medical. Both are drug addicted, sociopathic assholes that delight in being smart and figuring it all out before anyone else.

    Doctor Who, in some incarnations, is like that as well.

    I tried The Suburbs again...I don't get it. I can see why some people like it the best, but I like Arcade Fire best when they're histrionic, aim for the fences, and play BIG. I like the melodrama, not the more subtle, critic-pleasing "mature" stuff. Neon Bible was criticized for its overblown qualities, but that was what I loved about it. Less sensitive acoustic ballads, more gigantic church organ and songs about being a desperate kid.

    I really liked British Sea Power when they put out their first record...seriously "Carrion" is an AMAZING track. I liked their whole shtick. I saw them on their first US tour and the did the whole thing on stage with the taxidermy and local foliage, World War I doughboy outfits and everything...but they SUCKED! It sort of put me off of them until "Do You Like Rock Music", which I just sort of casually listened to. I haven't heard much else, thought I'd catch up with them.

  • avatarSan Il Defanso

    I think we're under-rating Yomi in this thread. I agree that Summoner Wars is better, but Stormcrow is right that they're apples and oranges.

    For me, Yomi has ended up being a game where I admire it more than I love playing it. I'm continually impressed by how well done it is, and the balance is remarkable. The thing is, it just doesn't compel me to play over and over again. I like the game a lot, and I still play it sometimes. But it's never fired that sector of my brain where I must play again.

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    Games- The reaction to Yomi is interesting. It is definitely a game that you either completely get or you don't at all. I like that quality about it, that it's divisive. I do think that having a good understanding about the deeper strategies of fighting games helps because it uncovers some of Yomi's more subtle intricacies. One of which is that the game is as much about psychology as it is cardplay.

    It did kind of fade over the year though, that's for sure. I think part of that is because people are mostly playing it online and not F2F...so the "community" for it is mostly online and not among game groups.

    Comparing Yomi and SUmmoner Wars doesn't make sense. That's like saying that Mortal Kombat and Archon are the same genre.

    What Matt said about Mage Knight is more or less why I picked it...it feels fresh and new, and it completely revitalizes the adventure game and saves it from the endless cycle of Talisman/Arkham Horror repetition while also salvaging the scope and breadth of Magic Realm. It's just about the only truly strategic adventure game on the market, and it does that without sacrificing story and dramaturgy for cold mechanics.

    Dragonstout, the good news is I've got like half a year of non-review material saved up.

  • avatarSpace Ghost

    I think it is unfair to claim Yomi is all about either getting it or not getting it ... that treads very close to the whole "these games of ours" schtick. There are plenty of 2-player card games that are just as much about psychology as Yomi; in fact, almost all of them are if you play them on a competitive level. And perhaps that is where Yomi shines, it brings the type of competitive level psychological play to a beginner's level, where it would take several plays to reach that with other games. I get Yomi just fine -- and I have payed it extensively online; however, I will never prefer it when compared to something like Twilight Struggle (my online go to game) as the psychological tension is much higher, but you don't achieve that razor-edge perfect balance until both players are dozens of games in.

    As to Mage Knight -- it is definitely an update to Magic Realm, but there are tons of sacrifices in terms of breadth. Mage Knight definitely does not make the ideas brought to bear in Magic Realm obsolete.

    As to House, he was designed to be a modern day Sherlock Holmes and there are plenty of in-show references (his apartment is 221B Baker St. for example, House is a play on Holmes, Wilson = Watson, he gets shot by a Jack Moriarty...on and on).

  • avatarSuperflyTNT

    It's not about "getting it" or not, it's about liking it, or not. I "get" Project Gotham Racing, but I'm not a fan. I like Forza instead. I "get" 'train games'. I just prefer 'goblin slaying games'.

    Simple preference. To say that "if you GOT X you would like it, so clearly you don't GET it" is an arrogant statement, which is fine, but it's fallacious, which is not.

    It's like someone saying "If you GOT Dominion you'd be a fanboi". Bollocks.

  • avatarJexik

    I really like Yomi. And my nephew (who I've also played 2d fighters with) loves it even more than Summoner Wars, and regularly asks to play it. He got so excited when he beat me two games in a row around New Year's.

    But I really like card games, especially two-player, asymmetric ones. There's more than enough room for me to play both.

    My favorite game of the year was Risk Legacy, much as Yomi took familiar card game concepts and turned them on its head I thought it was brilliant to take the basic Risk mechanics and turn it into an actually fun, episodic games that ruins and creates friendships with each game.

    I've still not played Eclipse or Mage Knight, and I don't know that I will. My usual gaming partners are relatives and other people in their 20s; games over 2 hours just don't fly at all.

    King of Tokyo I may have to get, or gift to a friend who'll appreciate it.

  • avatarpanzerattack

    My mate in work's dog is in this Sunday's episode of Sherlock. The guy who runs his dog training classes also provides the BBC with animals for TV shows and apparently thought that 'Dexter' the dog was the perfect animal to be an extra in a mad scientist's lab.

  • avatargroth

    Benedict Cumberbatch to play super villain in next Star Trek film.
    http://www.icv2.com/articles/news/21855.html

    How good a Doctor would Cumberbatch make in Dr. Who?

    (He would be the least sensitive to his human companions)

  • avatarBearn

    MK was a great choice for game of the year barnes. My wife and i picked it up recently and it just dominates our game time now. The amount of game in the box more than justifies the price and we are anxiously looking forward to expansions. It's the adventure game we were looking for that Defenders of the Realm really hasn't delivered on for us.

    Yomi is for sure good but you really have to have the right attitude to enjoy it. I myself do not like it but i know others that adore it.

    Ascension on the IOS is just absurdly addictive no question. I feel like Thunderstone will benefit greatly from an IOS version since the only part that sucks about it is the setup and reset time. This could be the year when the top games are actually the IOS versions they put out of older games. I am very curious to see if they can get Through the Ages and Alien Frontiers on IOS with a top notch AI.

  • avatarMsample

    Thunderstone app would ROCK. Esp once you get all the expansions, set up/take down is a drag, same for Dominion.

  • avatarNotahandle

    Michael Barnes  wrote:
    "A Chinese Ghost Story"
    Here's something we can agree on! Excellent, excellent movie, I've probably watched it on DVD maybe a dozen times. You'll enjoy ACGS 2 as well, check it out. (I don't know about ACGS 3 as it's unavailable for my region, still waiting.)

    "[Sherlock] If you are a F:ATtie that has watched and enjoyed this show, all I have to say is THANKS A FUCKING LOT for not telling me about it. It is AMAZING."
    To paraphrase Bulwyf: "Hey I posted on the Fort right after I watched the show a few days after it was on the BBC."

    Bullwinkle wrote:
    "BBC One just premiered the second season of Sherlock."
    Excellent! Thanks for mentioning it!

    And MattLoter, Ancient_of_MuMu, moofrank, Citadel know about it . . . looks like you're the only F:ATtie who missed it at the time, Michael. :p

  • avatarMattDP  - re:
    Ska_baron wrote:
    Um, am I really going to be the first to toss a congrats to Mr. Thrower on landing a NHS gig? Sweet!

    Yes, yes you are. And thank you very much, I'm really looking forward to it :)

    I really must watch some more Wuxia films. I've loved every one I've seen bar House of Flying Daggers which was merely reasonable. That Ghost Stories one sounds amazing. But, baby jail and all that.

  • avatarZMan  - re: re:
    MattDP wrote:
    Ska_baron wrote:
    Um, am I really going to be the first to toss a congrats to Mr. Thrower on landing a NHS gig? Sweet!


    Yes, yes you are. And thank you very much, I'm really looking forward to it :)

    I really must watch some more Wuxia films. I've loved every one I've seen bar House of Flying Daggers which was merely reasonable. That Ghost Stories one sounds amazing. But, baby jail and all that.


    Here is a list of more HK action films to see in no order, mixing old school chop socky and more modern fare:

    Forbidden City Cop (Stephen Chow)
    Five Deadly Venoms
    Crippled Avengers
    Hero of Legend
    High Risk (Die Hard and making a little fun of Jackie Chan)
    Iron Monkey
    Shaolin Soccer
    Master Killer (aka Master of the 36th Chamber)
    Magic Cop
    Wing Chun
    Drunken Master 2 (I believe that is the one)
    Shaolin Challenges Ninja (awesome!)
    Kid with the Golden Arm
    Once Upon A Time in China (there are 6 or so of these and most are really good)
    Fong Sai Yuk
    Mr. Vampire

    There are many more but my memory is bad and my DVDs are boxed in the garage.

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    I've seen (and owned) every one of those barring the Chow picture.

    I actually think Five Deadly Venoms is one of the most overrated cult films...it's just not that great. The _idea_ is awesome, but it just doesn't deliver. I find it really dull. The better pick is Chinese Super Ninjas (also known as Five Element Ninja and just plain Super Ninjas)...it's one of the more ridiculous, comic booky Shaw Brothers movies...but it's also more consistently fun to watch than some of their stuff. Chang Cheh (who also did the Venoms movies) was their best director.

    Master Killer is a must, as is Eight Diagram Pole Fighter. Crippled Avengers is one of those that you've really got to see to believe.

    I'd definitely add Operation Pink Squad 2 to the list, if only for the hilarious A Better Tomorrow jab. And all of the other weird-ass shit that goes on in it.

    Hong Kong horror is NUTS. Before the 80s and all the post-Mr. Vampire/Encounters of the Spooky Kind wuxia/comedy horror, they actually had some pretty grim, dark horror. Shaw Brothers did a series of three that are well worthing seeing, Black Magic, Black Magic 2, and Seeding of a Ghost. Human Skin Lanterns speaks for itself, as does Centipede Horror (YUCK). Killer Snakes is up there too.

    What else...Chinatown Kid...Sex and Zen (not porn, it's actually really good)...Storm Riders...the Tiger Cage movies...Girl with the Thunderbolt Kick...Come Drink With Me...Dragon Gate Inn...Peace Hotel...Full Contact...Tiger on the Beat...Pedicab Driver...Eastern Condors...I haven't watched most of this stuff in years, now I'm all in the mood for it.

    That's all not even mentioning the Woo/Chan/Li/Hark stuff, most of which is worth seeing from 1985-1997. After the handover to China, HK cinema just had the wind taken out of its sails IMO. There was a decade (the HK New Wave) that was just amazing, and if you were follwing this stuff at the time you could feel the end coming. Most of what I've seen post-1997 isn't all that great, aside from some of Donnie Yen's stuff.

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    Oh, and Matt- Bride with White Hair. It's the best Wuxia by far.

  • avatarShellhead

    Some of my favorite HK movies:

    The Killer

    A Heroic Trio

    The Legend of Fong Sai Yuk (both I and II)

    Iron Monkey (the original, not the remake)

    The Hitman (I especially love the final battle scene)

    The Bride with White Hair

    A Chinese Ghost Story

    Storm Riders

    Police Story III (Michelle Yeoh does a breath-taking stunt involving a motorcycle and a train)

    For nearly a decade, there was an old local theater that had stadium-style seating and showed a different HK movie every Saturday night at midnight. I was a regular. In recent years, I've only really been impressed by The Curse of the Golden Flower, and that was actually done mainland, not in Hong Kong. House of Flying Daggers and Hero left me cold somehow, though the cinematography was nice.

  • avatarNot Sure

    We had a Chinese owned dollar-theater when I was in junior college in hick California that would do double-feature Chinese films for a solid week every summer. We'd attend as many days as we could manage.

    Lots of Jackie Chan, some early exposure to the John Woo picture, etc. Brilliant. Police Story III was in there somewhere, and Hard Boiled, and some others. They all blurred together in a haze of painful asses and too many jumbo popcorn refills. I remember an awesome sequels day of Armor of God 2 and Project A 2.

    I loved Magic Cop. The Killer is one of my favorite films, transcending genre, just one of my favorites all-around.

    The one thing I see missing from those two otherwise excellent lists is "God of Gamblers".

  • avatarmoofrank  - Operation Pink Squad II

    One thing about the crazier HK comedy horror fantasy movies.
    A lot of these (Operation Pink Squad 2 is probably still my fave) are directed and written by a guy named Jeffery Lau. He also did Eagle Shooting Heroes, which is one of the least coherent movies I've ever seen.

    But also he was involved in the God of Gamblers movies, and directed a LOT of early Stephen Chow movies. A lot of the things that people like about Kung Fu Hustle and Shaolin Soccer is very obvious in the earlier Stephen Chow movies, and it was really the amazing A Chinese Odyssey movies (Jeff Lau) that made him a superstar. Those two movies are (very, very, loosely) based on The Monkey King novel.

    From what little I've found in English, Jeff Lau often would write while shooting, or improvise vast chunks of his movies on set. The end result are crazy, crazy things that careen in wild directions or where things just happen. In "Out of the Dark" Stephen Chow plays a ghostbuster who can communicate telekinetically with his spirit-seeing potted plant. One scene has a refrigerator fall from the sky in the background of a shot. It is not really reacted to or otherwise explained anywhere in the movie.

    Easily my favorite director just for the sheer lunacy and anarchy factor in his movies.

  • avatarmetalface13

    Count me as one of the Sherlock faithful. It's fantastic. And yes, House and The Doctor are both Sherlockian characters, although House is much more so. I recently read the guy who plays Sherlock is going to be a villain in the Star Trek sequel. Plus he's going to be the voice of Smaug in the Hobbit. He's got a nice, deep, smoldering voice that will be good for the classic dragon. Do check out Jeckyll, it's very good, except the ending. Still worth it though. Another BBC show I recommend is Being Human. Yeah it does vampires, werewolves and ghosts, but does it rather well.

    Starbase Orion, eh? I've never played Master of Orion but I always wanted to but never had much of a PC rig to play games on. Ascendancy for iPad is on sale for 99 cents. That's too much of a discount to not take a risk.

    I'm loving Ascension on iPad. Add me. =metalface13= is my gamecenter. I'm super excited the same company is doing the Summoner Wars app. I cannot wait.

  • avatarmetalface13

    I forgot to mention Arcade Fire, whom I saw at Austin City Limits. They were the closing acts and we were really tired, but we sat on the ground, chilled and played with taking long exposure photos and glow sticks. I haven't heard all their albums but I'm excited they are on Spotify now.

  • avatarNotahandle

    I'll second Z-Man's Iron Monkey (don't bother with IM2, it has nothing to do with the first). And Once Upon A Time in China is excellent, I've enjoyed the first three, didn't know there were more, I'll have to investigate. Mr Vampire and it's sequel are also highly recommended. (Maybe I should check to see if there're more?)

    And thanks to Z-Man's and Shellhead for mentioning The Legend of Fong Sai Yuk (both I and II), I'll have to check them out too.

  • avatarZMan

    I'm biased towards Five Deadly Venoms and cannot see its faults :) But I did try Chinese Super Ninjas and for some reason it did not resonate with me like the other films.
    The Kid with Golden Arm uses the same people as in 5 Deadly Venoms.

    Storm Rides and God of Gamblers fell flat for me. Storm Riders I expected a lot from - I wish they did more of those elemental ninja effects.

    I also tried to like God of Cookery (another Chow film) but I didn't like it much. His other films also don't rate as well for me: From Beijing with Love, The 60 Million Dollar Man, etc. They have some great moments of comedy is many of them but overall just didn't make it for me.

    I do urge you guys to check out Shaolin Challenges Ninja: Chinese man (Gordon Liu) marries Japanese wife and sort of insults her. So she sends her school after him and each Japanese guy challenges Gordon to a duel using similar styles. So sais vs butterfly swords, staff vs spear, etc. But the coolest is ninja vs Chinese ninja style.

    I really miss the Hong Kong action movies we showed at Gen Con. Since I did Shadowfist we sponsored 3 and half days of Hong Kong movies for about 5 years or so. Gen Con gave me the AV equipment, I brought the movies and the people to staff the room. I always scheduled the best stuff in the evenings where I would wind down before settling for the night. We played some awesome movies. (And to push our B-Movie games, we played Army of Darkness (later Dead Alive) on Sat. at midnight. Those were great times.)

    I could on for hours on this stuff. Michael is right that the movies coming out now from HK are not as good as what we saw in the past. This is why you have seen much talk about films from Thailand, Korea, etc.

    Ong Bak people raved about and it is good (don't like the sequels much). The Bodyguard you should watch cause it is funny and has a great Tony Jaa cameo. Chocolate I have but haven't seen but heard it was great.

    Anyway, lots to see.

  • avatarcraniac

    Interesting to see the hate or fatique with Summoner Wars. I guess I'll have to play it about 30 more times and see what happens, but so far I am digging the master set.

    Sherlock really is great, and giving Holmes ptsd was a great idea. I'm not sure if Sherlock and House have mild sociopathy or Asperger's.

    It seems like only yesterday that Earth Reborn was going to be the game of the year!

  • avatarSuperflyTNT

    For me, it's not fatique or hate. It's that I don't mind losing, ever, but I don't like LOSING EVERY TIME.

    I just suck at the game. For some reason my mix of bad dice luck, bad draws, and any other reason I can come up with to explain away my clear inadequacy, I never win. Like ever.

    So, I gave up on it.

    Trivia: I playtested ONE GAME of Summoner Wars a year or so before its initial release....and I played the Fallen Kingdom. :) At a Max and Erma's with a buddy who was in town, who WAS a real playtester. He had to share.

  • avatarJonJacob  - re:
    craniac wrote:

    It seems like only yesterday that Earth Reborn was going to be the game of the year!

    It got number two spot last year on Barnes list:

    http://www.gameshark.com/features/789/p_10/Cracked-LCD-179-2010-Game-of-the- Year-Edition.htm

    ... and it got number two in the F:AT readers choice last year too.

    It could have easily taken the top spot for either list as far as I'm concerned and this year it would still be a top contender.

  • avatarKen B.

    I wouldn't say there's hate or fatigue for Summoner Wars. It did pretty well in our voting this year.

  • ioticus  - re:
    SuperflyTNT wrote:
    For me, it's not fatique or hate. It's that I don't mind losing, ever, but I don't like LOSING EVERY TIME.

    I've got a long list of games that I never win at.

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    For me, Venoms fell into that "expectations set way too high by reputation" trap that a lot of cult films wind up in.

    What's not resonant about sun ninjas or a fight that's won by stepping on the bad guy's intestines? ;-)

    Storm Riders is pretty uneven...some of it is awesome, some of it is nonsensical, and some of it is just lame.. At the time, it was the only HK movie with CGI effects.

    The newer HK stuff just doesn't have that manic, making it up as we go along energy. Its all too expensive, too Hollywood...the uncertainty of HK and 1997 really inspired a lot of creativity.

    None of the Thai/Korean stuff has that either...there's really only been a couple of "Korean wave" movies that I thought were really good- the better Chan Wook Park films, The Host, the first Ong Bak

  • avatarcraniac

    It looks like Sherlock was recommended six months ago!

    here

  • avatarMr. Bistro

    I love The Suburbs. Sure, it's a very low-key album, but I identify with it a lot. May be too much - I can't even listen to Ready to Start.

    Mage Knight may not make Magic Realm obsolete (some would argue Magic Realm did that on its own), but MK isn't necessarily trying to go that route. Based on MK's success we are very likely to see expansions, and with expansions MK has the possibility of moving from an amazing game, to something legendary.

  • avatarSpace Ghost

    No doubt that there is much of Magic Realm that needs to be streamlined. And, I think that Mage Knight does quite well in updating it - but it does sacrifice some of the breadth and depth (and I agree that it isn't necessarily the goal of MK, but the similarities are so great that it is hard to argue that MK is at least not heavily inspired by MR). I think you are spot on in that expansions could elevate it to something legendary -- especially expansions that would promote character differentiation a bit more. Mage Knight is easily the best game of the year (although I am interested in seeing how Eclipse performs once I can actually lay eyes on it). The only I wish was a little different is the streamlining of the combat -- slightly too deterministic for my tastes; but, I can give it a pass as at least how units are used is interesting.

    Barnes top games matched up with mine almost identically, excepting that I haven't played Eclipse and my dislike of Yomi notwithstanding. If Chaostle would have been a little bit more "tight" and "clean" it would have stood a chance as well, but it has some of the qualities of older games that are more nostalgic rather than good design choices. Oh yeah, also a +1 for using dramaturgy -- haven't seen that since college.

  • avatarMr. Bistro

    I agree about character differentiation in MK. The skill system is great, and I like the character-specific deed cards, but they're not enough to make each character feel unique. It's a minor gripe, but it would be a great thing to see expansions gussy up.

  • avatarJonJacob

    What I like about the character differentiation in MK is that they start very similar and grow from there. I like that because it means that there won't be a balance problem.

    But much more than that I like it because you choose how your character is different from the others. Between spells, advanced actions, artifacts, and especially skill tokens you have an awful lot of choice with who your character will become. You can create asymmetrical characters all you like and give us pre-determined characters where the asymmetry is the same from game to game. Because they are designed that way. This game gives you choice.

    In Mage Knight you may never see the same characters in one game because they will grow in such unique ways it's almost impossible. The permutations are through the roof. I would much rather control how my characters are different then have the rules do it for me.

    As for the deterministic combat. It's only some tokens and even then it's only some of the time. I attack at night a lot and I quite often have no clue if I will survive. But it depends how you play. If you want to get those incredibly valuable artifacts from burning a monastery you will never know if you can until you try. I'd say it's being over emphasized by those who don't like it but I really like how it's kind of split. If you like that kind of combat it's there for you. If not, that's there for you too. That's a nice compromise in my mind.

    All that said. I imagine, based on expansions for Space Alert and Galaxy Trucker (two of the best expansions I have ever bought), that any expansions coming out for this will be must buys that could easily make the game twice as good as it is now. Either way there is more in this 60$ box then in any 60$ box I've bought in years.

  • avatardragonstout  - re:
    Michael Barnes wrote:

    I tried The Suburbs again...I don't get it. I can see why some people like it the best, but I like Arcade Fire best when they're histrionic, aim for the fences, and play BIG. I like the melodrama, not the more subtle, critic-pleasing "mature" stuff. Neon Bible was criticized for its overblown qualities, but that was what I loved about it. Less sensitive acoustic ballads, more gigantic church organ and songs about being a desperate kid.

    I like the big crazy melodrama best too. The Suburbs has that in spades...it's just one of those things that eventually clicks.

    I'm really extremely bad with first (several) impressions of albums, so I always listen to albums a whole bunch of times. With The Suburbs, I'll also say that I took a long period of not listening to it (after listening to it a few times upon first buy), and then I heard a live version of one of the songs, it clicked, and then the whole album completely clicked.

  • avatardragonstout  - re:
    Michael Barnes wrote:

    It did kind of fade over the year though, that's for sure. I think part of that is because people are mostly playing it online and not F2F...so the "community" for it is mostly online and not among game groups.

    Really, I think it's more that the game has an extended learning curve (which is why people were excited about it at the beginning), but doesn't actually offer even months of really devoted play (I'm talking an hour a day) that was claimed.

    More importantly, though, the designer sacrificed "fun" on the altar of "balance" and "depth". But I know a lot of people disagree.

    Michael Barnes wrote:

    Dragonstout, the good news is I've got like half a year of non-review material saved up.

    Sweet! You remain both the most eloquent and passionate writer about games and the one with the best taste for what is fun.

  • avatarMr. Bistro  - re: re:
    dragonstout wrote:
    More importantly, though, the designer sacrificed "fun" on the altar of "balance" and "depth". But I know a lot of people disagree.


    I can appreciate that sentiment. I was hesitant to play another game that exchanged my beloved dice with cards. But I was really surprised at just how involved MK's card combat (and other actions) felt. Part of it may be because you inevitably describe the action out loud.

    "Okay, I'm assaulting the troops at the keep. I can't make any good siege attacks right now, so they hit me for X. My guardsmen will step up and block them for me. Then I'm going to attack them with my rage ability, and I'm going supercharge it with some red mana, and bring in my golems for support. Freakin' killed them!"

    Right away I have a simple 1-turn combat that crushes anything I've ever experienced in an adventure game before. I actually get a bit of a Yeah, I'm Awesome rush each time I do something in Mage Knight, which is exactly what I want in a game like this.

  • avatardragonstout

    Hey Bistro, just realized that in my quote there I didn't include the game name; I was talking about Yomi, not Mage Knight. I'm pumped about playing Mage Knight (though wary of the ueber-tactical nature).

  • avatarjohnnyspys

    I just watched an old 1954 Sherlock Homes show and I was shocked just how much the new series borrowed from this show. From the Afganistan war, the tan, asking for a flat mate, and "is it alright if I play the violin". I think it is cool there was a tip of the hat, but I was really freaked to hear very similar dialogue in the 1954 show.

Only registered users can write comments!
Text Size

Top