Articles Reviews Barnestorming #4- Yggdrasil in Review plus water heater repair and Elizabeth Taylor
 

Barnestorming #4- Yggdrasil in Review plus water heater repair and Elizabeth Taylor Barnestorming #4- Yggdrasil in Review plus water heater repair and Elizabeth Taylor Hot

yggdrasilMan, do you know what I'd like to have for dinner? Barnestorming #4.

On the Table

This week in Cracked LCD I’m taking a look at Z-Man Games’ new Yggdrasil, a co-op “siege management” game that, strangely enough, I find makes for a better solo game than a multiplayer one. I’d almost go so far as to say that if you’re looking to play it alone it’s a recommendation, but with more players that recommendation starts to fade. It’s a neat, tight design but it’s missing some key elements that good co-op games need to stand out from the pack. There’s very little codependency and collusion, and the delegation of tasks is really shallow. But if you play it alone, those things don’t happen and what you’ve got is a pretty good solitaire that does, in fact, play sort of like a States of Siege game.

Speaking of Z-Man, Junta: Viva El Presidente is out now. You want this game. It’s awesome. It’s basically like the designers said “let’s take everything crappy out of Junta and leave the good stuff”. So what you’ve got is all of the fun parts but none of that boring, cheapjack wargame junk that takes forever and doesn’t really add to the game. There’s still dice combat and plenty of bad behavior, and the cardplay mechanics are almost exactly the same. But old Junta didn’t come with dictator glasses either. I’ll never go anywhere the original game again. Seriously.Staying, still, in the Z-Man frame of mind…I finally got to play Wars of the Roses last night. This is one of Bill Abner’s favorite games, and I sort of missed it when it came out. I wish that I hadn’t, because it’s a damn good game. It’s sort of a mix of El Grande, Diplomacy, Game of Thrones, and maybe a little Hammer of the Scots thrown in. Fairly complex, heavy, and with tons of nasty, nasty bribery that will make you want to punch somebody. I may actually just do a full review on it, I think it deserves more attention than it got.

I have Age of Industry in hand, so we’ll see if you guys bickering about it in the thread last time are right or wrong.

I also have the LOTR LCG, I was resistant to buying it due to the idiotic LCG format and the fact that I hate buying a full sized $30 box that contains 200 odd cards and a handful of counters. I think I do want to check it out, it sounds really good. I’ll write it up over the next week or so.

Malloc was in town last night, he came to the Hellfire Club. Played TI3 with Will Kenyon and drank a beer.

 

On the Consoles

My Brink review is up at NoHS. I love it, I don’t care what Metacritic says. Some of the negative reviews almost read like they were made up.

I’ve also got a review of Motorstorm: Apocalypse live at Gameshark. It’s not very good, despite some pretty spectacular destruction.

Like everyone else in the world, I’m playing L.A. Noire. Pictured is an example of gameplay. I don’t like it, and I’ll have a lot more to say about it later. There are definitely some great, great things about it, but the gameplay is ridiculously lacking and I swear that if I have to trail another car or chase some runner again, I’m shutting the game off. Last night I had a massive shootout with all of these gangsters on the set of DW Griffith’s Intolerance. Yeah, it was pretty dumb. A couple of nights ago I assembled some pipes for this lady’s water heater. Look past the razzle dazzle and there’s really not much of a game here.

 

On the Phone

You know, Tikal on the iPhone really isn’t all that much fun.

I just downloaded Orions 2, the sequel to one of the better CCG-style card battlers on IOS. It’s pretty neat, sort of a cross between Heroes of Might and Magic and a simpler CCG. TONS of depth and replay value, I think it’s a good pick at $2.99

I’m also messing around with Aralon a bit. It’s an attempt at doing an Oblivion-style Western RPG. It’s OK. It’s not really pulling me in like I’d like it to, and it’s already far too linear and MMORPG-influenced to really succeed.

First Touch Soccer, which is on sale for 99 cents, is a better IOS footballer than FIFA 11. It’s smoother, more streamlined, and more fun to play. The AI is ruthless, too. Bumpy Road is on the way over the ether, it looks pretty cute.

 

On the Screen

I watched Marwencol, the documentary about this poor schlub that gets severely beaten and sort of retreats into a bizarro World War II fantasy world he creates with dolls including some of those big military dolls that you assume that only weird old men buy. Eventually, some of them big city New York types catch wind of what he’s doing so he starts doing gallery shows of his photography. Good on him for turning tragedy around.

It’s definitely a compelling documentary that sort of unfolds certain particulars about the subjects life, leading to some “oh, OK” kinds of moments where what he’s doing starts to make sense. I won’t spoil it, but he’s definitely not quite the person at the end of the documentary you thought he was at the beginning. It’s pretty fascinating to see the level of detail and story that he’s given his private Utopia, where there’s a Pokemon villain-turned magical time-traveling witch named Deja Thoris (wha-?), a club where people come to watch catfights, frequent harassment from the SS, and weird fetish stuff.

My problem with it is that no matter how much I sympathize with this guy, what he’s doing is incredibly creepy and weird. It’d be one thing if he just made all of this stuff up, but he’s got people he knows involved as doll characters including one lady that pretty clearly doesn’t know how to take the fact that this weird guy plays with a doll of her. The film sort of darts around how crazy this all is, instead sort of lionizing what he’s done as some kind of self-administered therapy. I don’t buy it. But it’s a good documentary, definitely worth checking out.

I also watched Lifeforce, the 1985 Tobe Hooper space vampires movie this week. It isn’t very good, but I love some of the ideas in it. I love the beginning, when the crew investigating Halley’s Comet runs into the dead, bat-like creatures and the crystal “coffins” on the ship. There’s a cool, sci-fi Gothicism there that I just adore. The movie sort of falls apart on earth though and not even an early Patrick Stewart role can save it.

It’s one of those “coulda been great’ movies. I totally dig the space vampires concept, and it’s funny to me that Cannon Films (hell yeah) actually changed the name of the movie from Space Vampires (the Colin Wilson novel it’s based on) to Lifeforce to sort of classy it up.

Oh, and Steve Avery- the female vampire is topless for quite literally the entire film. In fact, when I googled "Lifeforce Vampires" the first picture was of Mathilda May, the actress, naked.

 

On the Turntable

Tubeway Army’s “Replicas” hasn’t left rotation, I just can’t get enough of that record.

I’ve also had Numan and Tubeway Army stations constantly on Pandora and the other day it decided that I might like to hear “Primary” by The Cure. I started to reach for the skip button, thinking “no Pandora, I gave up on listening to The Cure many years ago” but the song sort of caught me off guard. It reminded me of how awesome they were before they spiraled out of control for “Kiss Me Kiss Me Kiss Me” and went full-on arena rock/teenage makeout music for “Disintegration”.

So this sent me back to the good Cure records- “Three Imaginary Boys”, “Seventeen Seconds”, “Pornography”, even “The Head on the Door”. I love the skittery, tense pop-punk of their first singles, their more expansive but still restrained psychedelia, and early dance music excursions no matter how much “The Walk” sounds just like New Order. “Seventeen Seconds” is definitely their best, and listening to it brought back memories of being in a band in high school and playing “A Forest” at parties for like 20 minutes at a time, flangers and chorus pedals practically overheating.

It seems that the more Robert Smith started to look like Elizabeth Taylor, the worse they got. I can’t stomach anything they’ve put out in the past two decades at all. I still remember the crushing defeat felt by my goth friends when “Friday I’m In Love” was a hit single.

Next time- I dunno, maybe the LOTR LCG.

Powered by JReviews
Comments (22)
  • avatarHatchling

    About Marwencol, Michael Barnes wrote:

    Quote:
    My problem with it is that no matter how much I sympathize with this guy, what he’s doing is incredibly creepy and weird. It’d be one thing if he just made all of this stuff up, but he’s got people he knows involved as doll characters including one lady that pretty clearly doesn’t know how to take the fact that this weird guy plays with a doll of her. The film sort of darts around how crazy this all is, instead sort of lionizing what he’s done as some kind of self-administered therapy. I don’t buy it. But it’s a good documentary, definitely worth checking out.

    When I saw the film with my friends, we had a long conversation about the mixed feelings we had about Mark Hogancamp's fantasies.

    On the one hand, they were his therapy, in that they allowed him to try to piece back his memories (for those who don't know, the beating he suffered cause a lot of memory loss), and reclaim his identity and dignity by writing a different story about his life. The fantasies were part of a difficult effort to work through and transcend his trauma

    On the other hand, the narratives in fantasies did not reflect a healthy and healing perspective on the world by any stretch. They were vengeful. They were immature, in that they were filled with all or nothing, all good and all bad contrasts. They enabled him to play as though he was a god ruling over the world. In other words, his fantasies were filled with anxiety about control. He is another example of how only the deeply insecure have god-complexes.

    But it's clear that as someone who is dealing with heavy issues, he needs to start from where he's at, with all his neurotic and traumatized quirks. So in my opinion the fantasies are a mixed bag of healing and regressive elements. Somehow that weird mix allowed him to discover or develop in himself an amazing and artistic 'cinematic imagination' as Dr. Mabuse very nicely put it, and I think that's really interesting.

  • avatarjohnnyspys

    Wars of the Roses is probably in my top 5. The production value is over the top for the cost, and it is awesome with four but still pretty fun with two. Played with Vasel and a few FaT people at Gen Con last year and everyone talked about how cool the game screens and components were. You could play this game and D&D with those screens. I honestly don't know why this game isn't talked about more...although Zev said it moved pretty well for him. I hope he releases more games like this in the future.

    Hope you like Age of Industry, although I don't think that was what we were arguing about, because it is a great game, and the rules are more streamlined and flow better than Brass. The two sides of the board are cool and the water side can be fairly brutal when resources run low. Don't know your tastes enough yet to know whether you will like the game or love it but hopefully you will enjoy it.

    Dealing with music: I ask because of your tastes if you like Sisters of Mercy and The Mission? Perhaps even Echo and The Bunnymen or the Leather Nun? I saw The Creatures in Atlanta probably six or seven years ago and Einsturzende Neubauten as well. Some other cool shows I saw in Atlanta (when I lived in Tennessee) included King Diamond at the Mascarade (probably my favorite show there because he sounded awesome), Dillinger Escape Plan, The Black Dahila Murder, The Casualties, Killswitch Engage, Pinback, and A Flock of Seagulls (I have eclectic tastes.) I miss the venues in Atlanta especially the Masquerade. Fans in Chicago are so jaded compared to the crazy fans in Atlanta and Nashville.

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    Johnny, do you mean the Neubauten show in '93 at the Masquerade with Miranda Sex Garden? I was totally there, that's the last time they were in Atlanta. Amazing, amazing show.

    Of course I love the Sisters, are you kidding? Echo and the Bunnymen is one of my favorite bands too- a couple of weeks ago I was driving by the Masquerade to go to the Hellfire Club and out of nowhere, they were playing a show there. I heard nothing about it. I've seen them like four times though, but I would have seen them again.

    I saw the Creatures in '98/'99 (whenever "Anima Animus" came out) but they were TERRIBLE. Siouxsie was on the chubby side and Budgie just wasn't into it at all.

    Leather Nun? Dang. You're taking us back there! I haven't listened to them in years. I've stupidly missed King Diamond every time he's come through town, most notably when they did the Mercyful Fate reunion a couple of years ago. It was STUPID, three nights straight in Atlanta- Mercyful Fate one night, S.O.D. the next, and Danzig with the reunited Samhain the third. And I was deathly sick. I got better enough to go see Samhain at least, which really was what I wanted to see the most anyway.

    On War of the Roses, when I opened the 12 pound or so box, I couldn't believe it with those huge ass mounted screens and all that. Such a cool production. I think it didn't go over so well because it's really a strict four player game, it's got a strange partnership aspect that isn't common, and it's more complex than most Euros. It's like a halfway point between El Grande and Kingmaker, which is _ideal_ to me.

    Hatchling- those are some great observations, thanks for sharing them. I think that's what makes a documentary good, when it generates that kind of dialogue. I thought it was really kind of disturbing how he more or less replayed out the same story in the town as what happened in real life _and then_ the doll character created an even smaller fantasy town. That's seriously getting into some CRAZY psychology there.

    There's an aspect of the movie that kind of reminds me a lot of the Robert Crumb documentary...particular the parts about his brothers. It's fascinating to see that kind of raw psychology on the screen.

    But still, my favorite documentary about crazy folk is Grey Gardens, hands down.

  • avatarubarose

    Marwencol - the doll thing is not really that strange or uncommon. There's a large 'doll community' out there, and many, many boards and blogs devoted to picture stories, and written fiction with the dolls as the characters. Some very elaborate, well done stuff, as well as really far out stuff. Most of it is just cute, but a lot of people are working through their damage with their dolls, which are clearly a projection of the self.

  • avatarJeff White

    Michael, just wanted to add that I really like the new format. I really enjoy your paragraph length reviews at BGG (and wish they continued) and this is close to those.

    Thanks!

  • avatarStephen Avery

    Topless Vampires!!!

    I remember when this came out (Oh yeah I'm old- Like southernman's grandfather old) It is a good thing I didn't see it back then because I would have spent the rest of my life playing Vampire LARP and hitting on chubby goth chicks.

    Ygdrasil is becoming a guilty pleasure. I don't love the game but I have yet to beat it so I keep trying. It is clear they made a smoothly operating mechanics then tacked the Ragnarok theme to it. -and I HATE that. However the game play is solid and almost effortless. You play though it with the same ease as 7 Wonders and feel like you're on top of it but then it all falls apart right at the end. And you're like "If I just...If the die roll...We should have pushed back Loki and then it would've..." So While I think the gameplay is nothing to write home about, I still can't seem to win. And it makes me want to play it again.

    El Presidente' is the bomb. I've ordered mine. I'm totally enamored with the game. I like it even better than Intrigue- a bit less mean but a lot more flavor.

    I managed to get over to the swamp and yet again not hang with Barnes. However summer is almost upon us. So when we do meet after a years hiatus, the world will end. Get your gaming in now folks.

    Malloc showed up at the swamp and drank beer. How does that guy stay in shape? I am balloonign up like a tank top wearing Jabba the Hut and he hasn't changed a bit. My only recourse is to drink even more beer and crush him to death with my sizable gut.

    Steve"Boonowa tweepi, ha, ha"Avery

  • avatarjohnnyspys  - re:

    May 15 2004 show for Neubauten at the Masquerade. They tend to do these one off shows and there was very little publicity for the show. I only new about it because I was one of the record supporters for that release. I took a few of my students and because I had interviewed them before I got to take my students backstage which was a thrill for all. I think the creatures was around 2003 and it was during their tour with the Japanese Drumming team. I can't remember the name of the place but it was in the Little Five Points. Echo are a lot like Neubauten and do these crazy tours without much discussion. Although I am starting to believe it is because the music business is so broke that most of the promotion is done via Facebook which is great if you pay attention and pointless if you don't.
    My wife got to see the Leather Nun open up for the Psychedelic Furs back in 87, but I was never so lucky (that and I was more into hardcore punk and crossover metal at the time). Well the King is not touring right now because he had heart surgery but if he ever comes back you must go to the show...it is amazing and they were such a great live band when I have seen them, especial in the Abigail era. The first time I saw them was when they were touring with Flotsam and Jetsam
    for the No Place for Disgrace record. Ah the good times.

    Michael Barnes wrote:
    Johnny, do you mean the Neubauten show in '93 at the Masquerade with Miranda Sex Garden? I was totally there, that's the last time they were in Atlanta. Amazing, amazing show.

    Of course I love the Sisters, are you kidding? Echo and the Bunnymen is one of my favorite bands too- a couple of weeks ago I was driving by the Masquerade to go to the Hellfire Club and out of nowhere, they were playing a show there. I heard nothing about it. I've seen them like four times though, but I would have seen them again.

    I saw the Creatures in '98/'99 (whenever "Anima Animus" came out) but they were TERRIBLE. Siouxsie was on the chubby side and Budgie just wasn't into it at all.

    Leather Nun? Dang. You're taking us back there! I haven't listened to them in years. I've stupidly missed King Diamond every time he's come through town, most notably when they did the Mercyful Fate reunion a couple of years ago. It was STUPID, three nights straight in Atlanta- Mercyful Fate one night, S.O.D. the next, and Danzig with the reunited Samhain the third. And I was deathly sick. I got better enough to go see Samhain at least, which really was what I wanted to see the most anyway.

    On War of the Roses, when I opened the 12 pound or so box, I couldn't believe it with those huge ass mounted screens and all that. Such a cool production. I think it didn't go over so well because it's really a strict four player game, it's got a strange partnership aspect that isn't common, and it's more complex than most Euros. It's like a halfway point between El Grande and Kingmaker, which is _ideal_ to me.

    Hatchling- those are some great observations, thanks for sharing them. I think that's what makes a documentary good, when it generates that kind of dialogue. I thought it was really kind of disturbing how he more or less replayed out the same story in the town as what happened in real life _and then_ the doll character created an even smaller fantasy town. That's seriously getting into some CRAZY psychology there.

    There's an aspect of the movie that kind of reminds me a lot of the Robert Crumb documentary...particular the parts about his brothers. It's fascinating to see that kind of raw psychology on the screen.

    But still, my favorite documentary about crazy folk is Grey Gardens, hands down.
  • avatarmoofrank  - Vampires

    Lifeforce isn't really much of a Vampire movie. And the ending gets all 80's tedious giant vortex of fog and light and whooshing noises.

    It does have its moments. A great zombie puppet, and the aforementioned NUDE SPACE ALIEN CHICK.

    If you want a movie to turn people into Goths, go watch The Hunger. That was pretty much required viewing in the crowd I hung with. Bowie, Sigourney Weaver and Bauhaus.

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    WRONG Frank Branham. It's Susan Sarandon, not Sigourney Weaver. In the crowd I ran with, it was definitely essential viewing and replicas of that ankh-knife pendant where like holy grails. I love The Hunger, I think it's a really chic vampire flick. Dang...want to watch it now, kind of.

    That's right Johnny, I forget about that 2004 show...I was out of town when it happened, I remember now.

    Flotsam and Jetsam? Hell yeah!

    Steve, that's a good point about Yggdrasil, it's so slick and easy to play that it's hard not to enjoy it, even if you're breaking it down critically. "Effortless" is a great way of putting it.

  • avatarstormseeker75

    I played Yggdrasil last night with my wife. We had a good time. I looooooooove the art.

    Is it weird that I think the bag mechanism is super? I just love that you can add to bags and take away, but you never really know what you're going to pull. It adds so much tension!

  • avatarDr. Mabuse
    Quote:
    I thought it was really kind of disturbing how he more or less replayed out the same story in the town as what happened in real life


    Actually he created a fictious narrative based on incidents in his town, which in my opinion isn't disturbing at all. He also invented characters as you already mentioned like the time-traveller.

    Having the women of the village rescue his lead character(himself) from the Nazis is both horrific and beautiful (the Hero in the arms of his rescuer/lover.

    Quote:
    ... _and then_ the doll character created an even smaller fantasy town. That's seriously getting into some CRAZY psychology there.


    Truly, I mentioned this in Trash Talk but that "play within a play" reminded me of the film," Synecdoche, New York" with Philip Seymour Hoffman.

  • avatarwaddball

    Wars of the Roses does seem to have been overlooked. I've had it for a while but can't get it on the table. I think the double-guessing and the roshambo aspects turned people off, and it got dismissed as very chaotic, with a niche appeal.

    Curious on Ygddrasil: how does it stack up against Mousquetaires du Roy (other than the non-English names)? I've had my eye on both. Off the cuff, Ygg looks like a popcorn game, where you play it a few times and then trade it. MdR looks better on that front, maybe even very rich on decisions, but not so good solo. Recommendations?

  • avatarwaddball

    Oh, and doesn't El Presidente strip away all the roles of the original? That seems unfortunate.

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    Curious on Ygddrasil: how does it stack up against Mousquetaires du Roy (other than the non-English names)? I've had my eye on both. Off the cuff, Ygg looks like a popcorn game, where you play it a few times and then trade it. MdR looks better on that front, maybe even very rich on decisions, but not so good solo. Recommendations?

    Well, you pretty much have it down right there. Yggdrasil definitely is a much more "effortless" game than MdR, which takes a little work to get at. MdR is considerably more complex, but yes, it does have a lot more going on in it and situations are much more dynamic. There's a far greater sense of delegation in it.

    I think I'd definitely pick MdR over Yggdrasil, but if you are looking to play mostly solo, then Yggdrasil is actually the better choice even if its longevity might be in question.


    Actually he created a fictious narrative based on incidents in his town, which in my opinion isn't disturbing at all.

    It wouldn't be except for the acting out sexual fantasies toward uninterested women part. And I have to say that if I knew some guy down at the trailer park had a doll of me that he was acting out stories with, I'd be a little creeped out.

    Oh, and doesn't El Presidente strip away all the roles of the original? That seems unfortunate.

    You won't miss them one bit.

  • avatarstormseeker75

    I played Junta once upon a time. It was long, tedious, and boring but I loved the idea of the game. The military stuff is crap and just bogs things down. Hopefully El Presidente will fix what I didn't like.

  • avatarSuperflyTNT

    Didn't Lifeforce star Walter Koenig sans faux-Russkie accent? Or was that Moontrap? Either way, ogling vampire boobies can't be all bad.

    Thanks for the heads-up on Yggeblasdasfd or whatever. I was eyeballing it, but besides the fact that I have a rule about games with fucked up names being bad, more likely than not, this seemed pretty tame. Glad I didn't jump in.

    Good stuff, Michael.

  • avatarhotseatgames

    Koenig was in Moontrap. More like Mooncrap amirite?

    Friday I'm in Love is a travesty. My personal favorite Cure song is Boys Don't Cry... I don't know what album it's from. I didn't really listen to them until they had been around for a while.

  • avatarBlack Barney

    great article. I had always wondered about Lifeforce and if I should see it or not. Sounds cool. Man that Origins 2 game looks GREAT! I hope it comes to XBLArcade or the windows phone

  • avatarBlack Barney

    i remember b00bs in Moontrap and that's it. I remember it being a space version of VIRUS (Same movie on a ocean vessel)

  • avatarSuperflyTNT

    Is it just me or does Yggdrasil sound like some sort of new STD ointment? I'll never get why some games have such completely bollocksed names.

  • avatarwaddball

    Would Jörmungandr have worked better for you?

  • JJJJS
    Quote:
    Is it just me or does Yggdrasil sound like some sort of new STD ointment? I'll never get why some games have such completely bollocksed names.


    It's this:
    here

    Strange though it may be, considering the board depicts the tree and the nine worlds, the name fits.

Only registered users can write comments!
Text Size

Top