Articles Reviews Barnestorming #24- California, Elder Sign in Review, Nightcall
 

Barnestorming #24- California, Elder Sign in Review, Nightcall Barnestorming #24- California, Elder Sign in Review, Nightcall Hot

eldersign The Barnestorming #24 Horror

Late edition- I’m at John Wayne airport in Orange County, California about to get on the red eye back to Atlanta. Apparently these barbarians don’t know what a decent internet connection is out here. Orange County sucks. I have to come out here every year to stare at powerpoint presentations for a training meeting. We did have some fun though, I got to hang out with my team and I had a damned good $15 Old Fashioned. But yeah, Irvine- no good. Victory Point Games is out here and I thought about stopping by and bugging Alan Emrich, but I didn't have time. Or a ride.

 

On the Table

Elder Sign goes under the knife this week at Cracked LCD. I like the game, I really do. But it’s awfully messy, unbalanced, abstract, and flaky. I actually think it’s better solo than Arkham Horror. It is too easy. Sometimes. Other times, it’s brutal and unforgiving. It is a dice game and it has a specific scope, and as a weird kind of simulation of the board game it mostly works…apart from the fact that it doesn’t have any kind of meaningful narrative, atmosphere, or storytelling. Which are, of course, more important to Arkham Horror than the mechanics.

I just wish it was a smoother-playing design. It actually could have gone through the strainer another couple of times, I think. King of Tokyo is still the best dice game out there right now.

I’ve been soloing Sentinels of the Multiverse in the hotel room and a little Dragon Rage. Even played a solitaire Awful Green Things while watching Scott Pilgrim and eating strawberry tiramisu from a Taiwanese bakery, which was fun. Good stuff. Sentinels has some major problems, but I love the spirit of it and it’s the first superhero game that feels like comics. For god’s sake, the game actually _needs_ heart counters.

 

On the Consoles

Not much shakin’ this week since I’ve been away from home and console-less. Back home I’ve got a copy of Dark Souls waiting to beat me into submission.

Driver: San Francisco is really, really good.


Oh, and God Hand is on PSN. I can finally play the god damned thing. Everybody that’s played it says “Barnes, you need to play God Hand”.

 

On the Phone

Played a lot of First Touch Soccer on the plane out here, you F:ATtie footies ought to take a look at it, it’s better than the FIFA IOS games. But then Steve Jobs died. It really hit me yesterday how significant that man was to culture along a couple of different axes- moreso than Bill Gates or other tech-barons. Tip my iPhone to you, sir.

 

On the Screen

Damn, I want to see Driver. I tried to get some work folks drummed up to go to a theater out here to see it, but they’re lame and boring. No one wanted to be out past 9 o’clock.

More Doctor Who, of course. I just watched the whole thing with The Master, which I liked apart from when it went way over-the-top with the Doctor turned into a bizarre, wizened creature in a birdcage. But I did actually like The Master, nefarious and funny and a great foil to the Doctor. The Britney Spears thing was a bit much though.

I also watched the one with Agatha Christie. It’s funny how the show really avoids the whole “let’s meet famous people” thing for the most part, but when they do play that card it’s usually pretty tastefully handled. I liked Donna in this one, really funny stuff- “Harvey Wallbanger! Towering Inferno!”.

Getting close to exhausting the Tennant shows…I made a play-doh sculpture of six Daleks during the training meeting I’m at. I won the art contest. My other entry was a play-doh recreation of the “Dawn of Man” sequence from 2001.

 

On Spotify

I shit you not, I’m sitting here watching a syndicated episode of The Simpsons and they just had a scene with Giorgio Mordorer’s “The Chase” from the Midnight Express soundtrack. Which is also on this week’s playlist.

F:ATtie Tchoss posted last week looking for more songs like the track “Night Call” by the French electro artist Kavinsky. It’s a sexy, nighttime song straight out of 1982 meant to be listened to while driving at 2am in a Ferrari in the outskirts of a city. Pretty awesome. So I made a little playlist of songs that match up with that concept. There’s some synthpop, some obscure disco, a little touch of electro. It’s fun, and it’ll put you in the mood to test drive that Testarossa.

  • Chromatics- In the City
  • Black Devil Disco Club- The Devil in Us
  • Giorgio Mordorer- From Here to Eternity
  • Phil Oakey- In Transit
  • Gina X Performance- Kaddish
  • Liasons Dangerueses- Los Ninos del Parque
  • Neon Neon- Michael Douglas
  • Kraftwerk- Aerodynamic
  • Yello- Bostich
  • Gary Numan- Airlane
  • John Foxx- Underpass
  • Anne Clark- Sleeper in Metropolis
  • LCD Soundsystem- Get Innocuous!
  • Alexander Robotnick- Obsession for the Disco Freaks
  • Giorgio Mordorer- The Chase
  • Kavinsky- Nightcall

Next week- the secret origin of Black Sabbath.

Powered by JReviews
Comments (13)
  • avatartscook  - "Tchoss"

    The keys are like right next to each other.

    Your CLCD review is more or less exactly why I decided to not bother with Elder Sign.

  • avatardaveroswell

    The Elder Sign review may be the oddest mixed review I have ever seen you give.

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    It's really an odd game. The fact that it really is kind of a game about another game is weird. I stole that from Shellie, but I think it's right on the money.

    Like I said, I do like it, but every time I play it disappoints me to some degree. It just feels really underdeveloped, which is very strange for FFG. Having played a lot of Richard's prototypes, this feels just like one...it's almost like it's in a state of arrested development. Which is why we're seeing a lot of variants and house rules.

    Sorry Tscook- 2000 miles from home and drinking more than usual!

  • avatardaveroswell  - Reason I bought it

    A) Arkham is quickly becoming one of my favorites

    2) the only time I get to play Arkham is at a con, and I've been jonesing for a true solo version.

    The thing I HATE though is an unfinished game. This sounds like one of the few games I'd be willing to buy an expansion to it if it ironed out some kinks.

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    Oops- playlist link- http://open.spotify.com/user/factorygames/playlist/6OAN8Qhmj9NmuGx3fLoA29

  • avatarjohnnyspys

    Nice call on Kavinky...the only band today that comes close to this would be Lady Tron but this still has that 80s chilling Vibe of drug induced sadness, with the hope that something great is possibly around the next corner.

    I too am really digging Spotify...I just wish someone would make a free plugin so I could stream the music to my home stereo or perhaps my apple tv which is plugged into my stereo. If I remember, there were a few apps when I first got Spotify but they were pricey and didn't work that well. I haven't checked in awhile about streaming so do you know if you upgrade Spotify to one of their subscription plays whether one of the features is streaming audio to a PS3 or apple TV?

  • avatarubarose

    Elder Sign is an odd game. It's a toothless game. It's like playing cooperative Yatzee, which by the way is a pretty good way to play Yatzee with young children, but kind of a stupid way to play with a group of adults. However, despite this, playing Elder Sign still manages to be rather enjoyable.

    I kind of wonder if the seed idea for Elder Sign came from a non-coop prototype of Richard's that I played a while back. That game had some bite to it because you were competing to get the most of one of the things that you earned as a reward for beating an adventure card.

  • avatarMichael Barnes

    Yeah, toothless. There really should have been more adventures that cause negative effects when they're out to increase urgency and give the game a more hostile edge. As it stands, most stuff just sits there including monsters and the only time he game bites you is when you fail. In Arkham Horror, the monsters come after you. In Elder Sign, they politely wait for you to fail to roll a skull.

    Dave- I don't think the game is incomplete. It's actually more complete than most FFG games are. It's just that it feels like it needed more development.

  • avatarbfkiller

    Your review and other comments I've read about Elder Sign make it completely unappealing to me. It's almost the equivalent of designing a shorter Tales of the Arabian Nights by replacing the reaction matrix and book of tales with a spinner.

  • avatarmikoyan

    I have to go out to Irvine a couple years to help our other office with ISO stuff. I don't mind the area so much. There is a pretty cool store in Garden Grove with a decent selection of games and other things. John Wayne is a pretty cool little airport...easy in and easy out.

  • avatarGrudunza  - re:
    Michael Barnes wrote:
    It's really an odd game. The fact that it really is kind of a game about another game is weird. I stole that from Shellie, but I think it's right on the money.

    I think you stole that from me, but that's okay... I won't press charges.

    I don't think Elder Sign is a better solo game than AH, by any means, but I would say that it's a better solo game than AH if you only have an hour and a small table.

    I like it for what it is, quite a lot, actually, but it's definitely too easy and could have used more development. Here's hoping the inevitable expansions help out with some of the issues.

  • avatarSagrilarus  - re: re:
    Grudunza wrote:
    Here's hoping the inevitable expansions help out with some of the issues.

    MSRP of this with the first expansion thrown in will be . . . ?

    S.

  • avatarGrudunza  - re: re: re:
    Sagrilarus wrote:
    Grudunza wrote:
    Here's hoping the inevitable expansions help out with some of the issues.


    MSRP of this with the first expansion thrown in will be . . . ?

    S.

    Eh, it'll probably be a POD expansion for like $12-15, although it wouldn't surprise me if there will be a more substantial expansion at some point that includes another die or two, which probably wouldn't work for their POD model.

    I don't look at it that way, though, because I feel like I've gotten my money's worth so far. I enjoy playing it and have played probably 15-20 games. I can complain that it's too easy or underdeveloped or whatever, and I think that's definitely justified, but the value of having it, even as it is, is still worth it to me.

Only registered users can write comments!
Text Size

Top